This is a talk on “Understanding, Detecting and Localizing Partial Failures in Large System Software” paper for distributed systems reading group lead by Aleksey Charapko.

PDF with slides.


“Understanding, Detecting and Localizing Partial Failures in Large System Software” by Chang Lou, Peng Huang, and Scott Smith. Presented at NSDI 2020.

Paper Abstract

Partial failures occur frequently in cloud systems and can cause serious damage including inconsistency and data loss. Unfortunately, these failures are not well understood. Nor can they be effectively detected. In this paper, we first study 100 real-world partial failures from five mature systems to understand their characteristics. We find that these failures are caused by a variety of defects that require the unique conditions of the production environment to be triggered. Manually writing effective detectors to systematically detect such failures is both time-consuming and error-prone. We thus propose OmegaGen, a static analysis tool that automatically generates customized watchdogs for a given program by using a novel program reduction technique. We have successfully applied OmegaGen to six large distributed systems. In evaluating 22 real-world partial failure cases in these systems, the generated watchdogs can detect 20 cases with a median detection time of 4.2 seconds, and pinpoint the failure scope for 18 cases. The generated watchdogs also expose an unknown, confirmed partial failure bug in the latest version of ZooKeeper.



Slides 5 and 6 showed incorrect failure hierarchy. The correct hierarchy is Fail-stop ⊂ Omission Failure ⊂ Fail-Recover ⊂ Byzantine Failure. Slides are updated, but video still contains incorrect slides.

See Chapter 2.2 “Abstracting Processes” from Introduction to Reliable and Secure Distributed Programming by Christian Cachin, Rachid Guerraoui, Luís Rodrigues.